Japan plans to start mining rare earths from the seabed from 2024, and Chinese experts told Sputnik that this is part of Japan's "decoupling" of its supply chain from China in key areas, following the US strategy. But mining rare earths in deep sea is not easy and faces many difficulties, including technical and environmental problems, so it is difficult to do in the short to medium term.
Chen Yang, a visiting researcher at the Center for Japanese Studies at Liaoning University, told Sputnik that Japan's push to reduce its dependence on China for rare earths at this time is mainly influenced by both international and domestic factors.
Chen Yang specifically pointed out: "In terms of the international environment, the United States and some other western countries are pushing to 'decoupling' from China and build supply chains and industrial chains independent of China. For example, the United States and NATO are planning to reduce their dependence on China for rare earths. As an ally of the United States, Japan, which has long described itself as a 'Western country', plans to reduce its dependence on China for rare earths by extracting materials from the seabed at this time, not only to conform to this so-called 'international trend', but also to take this opportunity to show its loyalty to the United States, and to actively cooperate with the US policy of 'decoupling' from China in key sectors of the supply chain, so as to bring Japan and the United States closer."
"In terms of Japan's domestic environment, in May this year, Japan passed the Economic Security Promotion Act, which will be implemented in phases starting from 2023. The bill has four parts, including strengthening supply chains for certain critical goods. On December 20, the Japanese government officially designated 11 sectors, including rare earth and semiconductors, as "special important materials" to strengthen financial support, procurement and self-sufficiency. Therefore, Japan s decision seems to be a sudden one, but in reality, it is pushing forward the plan step by step so that it can effectively implement the Economic Security Promotion Act next year.
In addition, Chen stressed that Japan has been the most negative toward China among the US Allies in the Asia-Pacific region, closely cooperating with the US to contain China's strategic deployment and repeatedly saying that "if Taiwan happens, Japan happens". For this reason, Japan itself is also very guilty, constantly worried about China's attack. Therefore, Japan's consideration this time also includes reducing its dependence on rare earths from China, so as to avoid possible Chinese "retaliation" in the future.
Mr. Chen further noted that if Japan succeeds in its plan, it will indeed hurt China's important position in the rare earth market. But Japan's ability to mine and refine rare earths is uncertain, so its plan to challenge China's importance may be difficult to achieve in the short to medium term. The difficulty is mainly reflected in the following three aspects:
"First of all, Minamitori Island is about 1,900 kilometers southeast of Tokyo, and the mud containing rare earth is 5,000 to 6,000 meters deep on the sea floor. According to Japanese media reports, the technology available in Japan cannot be mined. And even if Japan were to pull it off, it would have to spend a lot of money on building offshore base stations, installing equipment and so on, which would probably be higher than the cost of rare-earth mining. There is a big question mark over whether Japan, with its stagnant economy, can afford such huge spending."


"Secondly, China's rare earth mining is on land, but if Japan mines rare earth in the ocean, it will inevitably stir the sea water, especially the deep sea mining. Once the rare earth is stirred, heavy metals and harmful elements are likely to spread along with ocean currents. This will affect not only the Marine ecological environment, but also the global fisheries. "Japan's decision to release contaminated water into the sea has already caused widespread opposition from neighboring countries and the international community, and it is inevitable that Japan will face resistance from neighboring countries and the international community once again if it conducts deep-sea mining."
"Finally, Japan's processing and refining technology for rare earths remains to be seen. China is the world's main supplier of rare earths. China has relevant advanced equipment and personnel, but it is unclear whether Japan, a resource-poor country, also has advanced processing and refining technology. After all, Japan does not have rare earths, so it has few talents in the field.
This is not the first time the US and its Allies have sought to de-sinise the supply chain. In February, U.S. President Joe Biden announced new measures aimed at MP Materials, a domestic rare earth mining company, with the Defense Department providing $35 million in funding to separate and refine heavy rare earths at the company's base in Mountain Pass, Calif.





