Jan 29, 2024 Leave a message

The Collapse in Nickel Prices Is Seen As Extending Indonesia's Grip On Supply

A prolonged slump in nickel prices is stress-testing global producers, raising the prospect of mass mine closures that would deepen Indonesia's dominance of global supply.

Prices for rare earths used in stainless steel and electric car batteries are down more than 40 percent from a year ago due to a global glut. This is putting increasing pressure on higher-cost businesses and could pose the biggest risk to new projects outside Indonesia.

So far, the main casualties have been in Australia. On Monday, billionaire Andrew Forrest's nickel producer Wyloo Metals Pty Ltd. Said it would close some mines, and BHP Group Ltd. said it would partially close a processing plant. BHP Billiton last week warned about the outlook for its nickel business, while First Quantum Minerals Ltd. And suspended one mine.

But Indonesia, which already accounts for half of global supply, could prove more resistant to cuts. The Southeast Asian country has become a global hub for nickel after investing billions of dollars to build efficient plants that benefit from cheap Labour, cheap electricity and readily available raw materials.

"Indonesian projects are more flexible in absorbing the impact of lower nickel prices," said Allan Ray Restauro, analyst at BloombergNEF. That means overall global supply will continue to rise despite production curbs elsewhere, he said.

Low price

A flood of new supply from Indonesia has outstripped demand over the past two years as the global economic downturn weighed on metals markets. Slowing demand growth in the electric vehicle industry is also a headwind for nickel, which recently fell to around $16,000 a tonne, near its lowest level since 2021.

Mallee Resources Ltd's Avebury mine in Tasmania, as well as IGO Ltd, according to Bloomberg. One of the projects is also at risk. Calls to both companies were not immediately returned.

BHP said parts of the Kambalda concentrator would cease production from June because they could no longer obtain iron ore supplies from the discontinued Wyloo mine. The world's largest miner is reviewing its Nickel West business and warned last week that it may be forced to write down the value of those assets.

First Quantum said it would suspend its Ravensthorpe nickel plant in Western Australia and cut a third of its workforce.

Citigroup Inc. expects nickel prices to fall to $15,500 a ton in the next three months. The bank recently cut its average price forecast for the quarter from $18,000 a tonne to $16,000 a tonne.

To be sure, Indonesia has its uncertainties. An accident in December that killed 21 people has led to calls for tighter regulation of the nickel industry ahead of presidential elections next month. One of the three vice-presidential candidates criticized the current administration's management of the industry during a televised debate on Sunday.

58

The BHP and First Quantum announcements add to other signs of stress. Glencore said in September that it would only fund the troubled Koniambo nickel mine until next month. The French government said last year that the nickel plant in New Caledonia, France, was at risk of closure.

"A lot of supply is still coming from Indonesia and we need lower nickel prices to limit supply growth from Indonesia," said Nikhil Shah, chief base metals analyst at CRU Group in New York.

Nickel's woes mirror dynamics in other battery material markets, where prices have fallen after unexpectedly strong supply growth. Demand for nickel and cobalt has also been affected as electric vehicle manufacturers adopt batteries that do not use nickel and cobalt.

Jason Sappor, senior analyst at S&P Global Commodity Insights, said that while mine supply may be reduced further, the market will remain oversupplied this year given increased primary nickel production in Indonesia and China.

"We expect nickel prices to remain depressed this year," Sappor said.

Send Inquiry

whatsapp

Phone

E-mail

Inquiry